Illinois Real Estate Investing: Best Cities & Neighborhoods for ROI

Illinois real estate investing offers one of the most diverse real estate markets in the U.S., offering opportunities in both high-density urban areas like Chicago and affordable suburban and rural markets. Whether you’re looking for rental income, fix-and-flip deals, or long-term appreciation, Illinois has investment options that cater to a range of strategies.

Join Flipsquad, the leading platform that connects real estate investors with high-value properties, market data, and expert insights to maximize ROI as we explore the Illinois market.

Illinois Real Estate Investing Market Overview

• Median Home Price (Statewide): ~$260,000
• Median Rent: ~$1,800/month
• Property Tax Rate: ~2.16% (One of the highest in the U.S.)
• Best ROI Areas: Chicago (multi-family), Rockford (affordable single-family homes), Peoria (cash flow rentals)
• Population: 12.5 million (some areas declining, others growing)
• Landlord-Friendly Score: Moderate (Eviction process can be lengthy, but rental demand is strong)

Best Cities & Neighborhoods for Real Estate Investing in Illinois

1. Chicago – Best Neighborhoods for High ROI

Best for: Multi-family rentals, short-term rentals, and appreciation plays.

Chicago is a prime real estate investment hub with one of the strongest rental markets in the Midwest. The city has a population of 2.7 million and an extensive job market, driving housing demand.

While high property taxes (averaging 2.25% of assessed home value) are a challenge, rental demand remains high, especially in areas undergoing gentrification. The city’s rental vacancy rate is 5.4%, reflecting strong occupancy levels.

Best Investment Neighborhoods:

West Loop – High rental demand, urban growth, and strong appreciation. Average home price: $550,000.

Bronzeville – Gentrifying, strong upside, more affordable entry. Average home price: $340,000.

Hyde Park – Home to the University of Chicago, ensuring strong student rental demand. Median rent: $1,900/month.

• Median Home Price: ~$310,000
• Median Rent: ~$2,200/month

2. Aurora Real Estate: Affordable Properties & Rental Growth

Best for: Single-family rentals and long-term appreciation.

Aurora is one of the fastest-growing cities in Illinois, with a population of over 180,000 and a 5.3% job growth rate over the past five years. The city offers affordable homes, with a median home price of $280,000, making it 30% cheaper than Chicago while still benefiting from proximity to the metro area.

With a low rental vacancy rate of 4.8% and an average rent of $1,900/month, Aurora presents a steady rental demand. It’s a great option for investors seeking long-term buy-and-hold properties, especially in neighborhoods experiencing economic and infrastructural growth.

Best Investment Neighborhoods:

Fox Valley – Strong rental market, good schools, growing demand.

Downtown Aurora – Urban revitalization, new businesses, rising home values.

Stonebridge – High-end rentals, proximity to golf courses and top-rated schools.

• Median Home Price: ~$280,000
• Median Rent: ~$1,900/month

3. Naperville Real Estate: High-End Homes & Long-Term Investment

Best for: Luxury rentals, high-end flips, and long-term appreciation.

Naperville is one of the wealthiest suburbs in Illinois, boasting a median household income of $127,648, nearly double the state average. The city is home to top-rated schools, a low crime rate, and a strong local economy, making it highly desirable for families and professionals.

Though properties are expensive, with a median home price of $500,000, demand remains strong, driven by its 1.8% annual population growth and low rental vacancy rate of 3.7%. High-end rentals perform well, with median rents averaging $3,000/month, catering to corporate executives and affluent renters.

Best Investment Neighborhoods:

Downtown Naperville – Luxury condos, high walkability, strong rental demand.

Ashbury – High-end single-family homes, great for long-term appreciation.

White Eagle – Exclusive golf course community, stable high-value market.

• Median Home Price: ~$500,000
• Median Rent: ~$3,000/month

4. Rockford Real Estate: Low-Cost Properties & High Rental Yields

Best for: Affordable rentals, and fix-and-flip.

Rockford offers some of the most affordable real estate in Illinois, with a median home price of $160,000, nearly 40% lower than the state average. This makes it an ideal cash-flow market, particularly for investors seeking high rental yields.

While appreciation is slower than in other cities, Rockford’s rental vacancy rate of 6.2% is relatively low, reflecting stable tenant demand. The city’s job market is supported by manufacturing, healthcare, and logistics, with major employers like Swedish American Hospital and Collins Aerospace helping sustain economic activity.

Investors benefit from low-cost property acquisition, with many single-family homes and duplexes priced under $150,000, making it an attractive option for first-time and seasoned investors alike.

• Median Home Price: ~$160,000
• Median Rent: ~$1,400/month

Best Neighborhoods for Investors:

Southeast Rockford – Affordable single-family homes with strong rental demand.

Downtown Rockford – Revitalization efforts are increasing property values.

5. Peoria Real Estate: Best Areas for Cash Flow Investments

Best for: Affordable rentals, student housing, and BRRRR strategies.

Peoria is an underrated investment market with a low cost of entry and high rental yields. The median home price in Peoria is $170,000, making it significantly more affordable than other Illinois cities.

Investors looking for strong cash flow can find duplexes and small multi-family properties at low prices, with median rents around $1,300/month. The city’s economy is driven by healthcare, education, and manufacturing, with major employers like Caterpillar Inc., OSF Healthcare, and Bradley University, ensuring a stable tenant base.

Peoria also boasts a rental vacancy rate of 5.8%, making it a viable option for buy-and-hold investors.

• Median Home Price: ~$170,000
• Median Rent: ~$1,300/month

Best Investment Areas:

Downtown Peoria – Higher appreciation potential, near businesses and hospitals.

North Peoria – Strong demand for family rentals, good schools.

Top Investment Strategies for Illinois Real Estate Investors

After identifying the best cities and neighborhoods for investment in Illinois, the next step is selecting the right strategy to maximize returns. Investors can leverage different approaches depending on their financial goals, risk tolerance, and market conditions. From multi-family rentals to fix-and-flip projects, understanding these strategies will help you build a profitable real estate portfolio.

1. Multi-Family Rentals (Best in Chicago & Rockford)

• Chicago’s multi-family market is thriving due to strong rental demand and high-density living.
• Rockford offers low-cost multi-family properties with strong cash flow potential.
• Look for duplexes and triplexes in gentrifying areas to maximize ROI.

2. Fix-and-Flip (Best in Rockford, Aurora, & Peoria)

• Illinois has a high number of distressed properties, making it ideal for flippers.
• Rockford and Peoria offer low-cost homes with solid after-repair values (ARVs).
• Focus on emerging neighborhoods and areas with new infrastructure projects.

3. Short-Term Rentals (Best in Chicago & Naperville)

• Downtown Chicago has a booming short-term rental market with Airbnb-friendly areas.
• Naperville attracts corporate travelers and visiting professionals, making it an attractive STR location.

4. Buy-and-Hold (Best in Aurora, Peoria & Naperville)

• Aurora and Peoria offer affordable homes with strong rental demand.
• Naperville offers stability, attracting high-income renters.

5. BRRRR Strategy (Best in Rockford & Peoria)

• Buy, rehab, rent, refinance, and repeat (BRRRR) works well in Rockford and Peoria due to their low-cost properties and high rental demand.
• Investors can recycle capital quickly for multiple property acquisitions.

Biggest Risks of Illinois Real Estate Investing

While Illinois presents a wealth of real estate investment opportunities, it is essential to recognize and plan for potential challenges. Property taxes, population shifts, and tenant regulations can all impact profitability. Successful investors mitigate these risks by targeting high-growth areas, leveraging local market knowledge, and using strategic investment approaches.

1. High Property Taxes

• Illinois has one of the highest property tax rates in the country (~2.16%).
• Best way to mitigate: Invest in areas with lower tax burdens, such as Rockford and Peoria.

2. Population Decline in Certain Areas

• Some parts of Illinois, including smaller towns, are losing residents, impacting demand.
• Best way to mitigate: Invest in growth areas like Chicago suburbs, Rockford, and Peoria.

3. Tenant Protection Laws

• Illinois has moderate to strict eviction laws, especially in Chicago.
• Best way to mitigate: Screen tenants thoroughly and invest in landlord-friendly cities.

Is Illinois a landlord-friendly state?

Illinois has a moderate landlord-tenant climate. While areas outside of Chicago may be more landlord-friendly, eviction laws in Chicago are more tenant-favorable. Investors should research local ordinances before purchasing rental properties.

Which cities in Illinois offer the best rental yields?

Cities like Rockford and Peoria offer some of the highest rental yields due to low property costs and stable tenant demand. These markets are ideal for cash-flow-focused investors.

Is Chicago still a good place to invest?

Yes. Despite higher property taxes, Chicago remains a top market due to its large population, rental demand, and diverse economy. Neighborhoods like Bronzeville and West Loop offer strong appreciation and rental potential.

What are the risks of investing in Illinois real estate?

The biggest risks include high property taxes, slower population growth in some areas, and strict tenant laws in certain municipalities. These can be mitigated by targeting high-demand cities and carefully screening tenants.

What investment strategies work best in Illinois?

Multi-family rentals in Chicago, fix-and-flip projects in Rockford, and BRRRR strategies in Peoria are all viable. Short-term rentals are also strong in Chicago and Naperville.

---

How Flipsquad Helps Investors Find the Best Property Deals

Flipsquad offers a powerful suite of investor tools, AI-driven property analysis, and market data insights to help investors identify the best opportunities in Illinois. Whether you’re looking to flip houses, invest in rental properties, or optimize your real estate portfolio, Flipsquad ensures you make data-driven decisions for maximum ROI.